The Fredösphere

See the Music Page for
more information about
my choral compositions.

Thursday, January 13, 2005

Being There

I turned on the radio during the drive to work this morning.  I turned to WGTE out of Toledo.  They were playing a Stokowski transcription of music from act III of Parsifal.  In a moment, I was There.

I haven't been There in a long time.  Wagner used to be my favorite composer, but maturity (or simple overexposure) has cooled my passion for that kind of over-the-top emotionalism.  Sadly, I was also turned off by listening to a Ring Cycle lecture on CD delivered by Peter Allen, who was for many years the famous voice of the metropolitan opera broadcasts.  Allen loves Wagner opera and knows it well, and he has a voice I could gladly listen to all day.  Yet, in spite of his enthusiasm, the plain truth of The Ring leaked out:  it has a dumb plot .  Siegfried is an uninspiring hero.  His only two accomplishments -- slaying the dragon and scoring with the broad in the horned helmet -- are purely selfish acts.  The guy's got no community service in his resume.  Then comes the whole embarrassing business with the magic potion that makes him a helpless puppet.  The final unforgivable indignity happens during the whole shark scene where Wagner has Siegfried visiting Florida so he can go water skiing.  This is lame, people.

I think the best packaging of the Ring is a CD called The Ring Without Words.  Lorin Maazel condenses the entire cycle into one hour of purely orchestral music.  You know me; normally I would prefer to hear the voices, but in this case I think this trampling on the composer's intention is okay.  I am somewhat familiar with the motifs and their meanings, so I can let the drama play out in my head while the music is playing; I'm not sure how much someone without that information would enjoy this disc.

Back to Parsifal.  I've ignored the opera down through the years.  I mainly know of it from an organ transcription of the prelude by Anthony Newman.  So many people have been bored by the opera, I've been scared off.  Today's broadcast reminded me it occupies it's own unique emotional space.  It reminds me of a gorgeous choral piece, the Corpus Christi Carol by Trond Kverno (hear far too little of it here and read a version of the text here) which recaptures Parsifal's strange, heterodox ambiance, the music that most perfectly expresses Wagner's carnal spirituality of asexual eroticism.

Carnal spirituality of asexual eroticism.  If you understand what that means, please let me know.  Or better, don't let me know; rather, seek professional help.  Like Wagner's music, these words intoxicate me by their strange beauty, not their meaning.

2 Comments:

Blogger Marcus Maroney said...

Man I really love that Maazel disc when I don't want to hear vocal wobbling. I hope you've heard Anna Russell's hilarious take on it - one of the best classical-comedy bits I've ever experienced.

Re: Parsifal - it only works for me live. I couldn't last through my recordings of it but had no problem sitting through it twice at the Met a few seasons back. I thought I'd have a new appreciation at home with the headphones on but still couldn't sit through it (despite owing several "legendary" recordings, whatever that means...). I even tried a DVD (a medium which cured my allergies to Prince Igor and Lucia) but nothing kept my attention like the real deal...maybe it's just me!

2:54 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Why is excerpting instrumental music from opera, "trampling on composer's intentions"? Wagner himself excerpted the instrumental music, and often composed endings to be used in non-theatre performers. Also, instrumental movements from opera usually stand well enough on their own. Even if the themes from the Ring appear in so many places, Siegfried's funeral march is great music whether you have heard the rest or not.

9:45 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Explore the Fredösphere

Home/Blog
Music Downloads
Psalm Chants for Worship
New World Order
Fountainhead Revisited

Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]



Umie the Umlaut says, "ask your doctor about the Fredösphere!"



Wikio - Top Blogs - Classical music


Powered by Blogger


Add to Technorati Favorites

Music

Sequenza 21
New Music Box
A Cappella News
Naxos Recordings
Michael Daugherty
Bolcom & Morris
Leslie Bassett
Bright Sheng
Createquity by Ian Moss
A2 Cantata Singers
A2 Choral Union
U-M School of Music
UMS
Meet the Composer
American Composers Forum
CPCC
Opus 1, a world-wide concert list
ChoralNet
Choral Public Domain Library
Theremin World
A2 Traditional Music & Dance
Saline Fiddlers
Old Tyme

Music Blogs

The Rest Is Noise by Alex Ross of the New Yorker
Greg Sandow on the future of Classical Music
PostClassic by Kyle Gann
Renewable Music
Jessica Duchen, a Critic in the UK
Ionarts, D.C. Critics
Sequenza21 Composers Forum
Aworks: new American classical music
Brian Sacawa: Sounds Like Now
Sounds & Fury
Twang Twang Twang
Steve Hicken: Listen
Musical Perceptions
Marcus Maroney
Scuffulans hirsutus
The Standing Room, a singer in SF
Iron Tongue of Midnight, another SF Singer
The Well-Tempered Blog
Texas Best Grok, home of the Carnival of Music
Hurd Audio
Felsenmusick

Art & Culture

The New Criterion and its blog Arma Virumque
About Last Night by Terry Teachout and OGIC
Two Blowhards
A Sweet, Familiar Dissonance
Arts & Letters
Arts Journal
Arion
Mark Steyn
Movielens
Plep
Byzantium's Shores

Ann Arbor & Ypsilanti

Arborweb by The Observer
mlive
The News
Woodward Woodworks
Polygon, the Dancing Bear
Ypsi Dixit
St. Luke Lutheran
The Detroit Page

Blogösphere

The Corner
James Lileks
Createive Commons
Andrew Cusack, the most Catholic Being in the Universe
Bookish Gardener
Gravity Lens

Whackösphere

Dr. Enuf
Soda Constructor
Kombucha